Book Review: Good Girl, Bad Blood by Holly Jackson
When I first plunged into Good Girl, Bad Blood, the sequel to Holly Jackson’s gripping A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, I was filled with a mix of excitement and trepidation. The first book had left me breathless, and I was curious to see if Jackson could recapture that magic. With a leap of faith, I opened the pages to follow Pip once more, and I was not disappointed.
Pip Fitz-Amobi, our intrepid detective-turned-podcaster, is back, but she’s grappling with the heavy consequences of her first investigation. After a series of life-shattering events, she has reluctantly hung up her sleuthing hat, much to her family’s relief. Yet, as life often does, it pushes her back into the fray when Jamie Reynolds—her friend—mysteriously disappears on the anniversary of a tragedy that rocked their town. Pip’s initial inclination is to let the police handle it, but as the stakes rise, she realizes that she cannot remain passive. Thus begins her journey back into the detective world, reigniting her podcast with new urgency.
The book opens with a slower pace, allowing readers to reacquaint themselves with Pip’s inner turmoil and her struggles against familial expectations. However, the narrative quickly picks up speed, launching into a thrilling investigation that is more captivating than its predecessor’s. While it dips into mature themes, such as manipulation and emotional abuse, Jackson deftly balances these weighty issues with a plot that hums with tension and suspense.
One precious takeaway from this book is its examination of toxic relationships. Pip’s revelations regarding the impact of harsh words and degrading labels linger long after the last page. As a reader, I couldn’t help but reflect on how deeply names and judgments can wound. It’s not just the mystery that hooks you; it’s the relatable and poignant insights about kindness, self-worth, and the fragility of relationships.
I found myself highlighting several quotes that resonated with me, sparking thoughtful conversations in my mind: “Hunches have to follow the evidence, that’s how this works,” is not just a mantra for Pip but a lesson for all of us in discerning truth from emotion. Soon, I was ruminating on others, like, “What do you do when the things that are supposed to protect you, fail you?” These lines linger in the air like a haunting echo, urging us to introspect our own lives.
While Jackson’s writing excels in many areas, the latter half of the book felt a tad less polished. The introduction of a subplot that seemed to diverge from the central mystery might leave some readers feeling slightly disoriented. Additionally, a vandalizing episode drew criticism for its portrayal and resolution, leading me to question the choices made in character decisions.
Despite these misgivings, I still found the overall experience immersive, rating this sequel 4/5. The characters are fleshed out, the tension builds beautifully, and Pip emerges as an even more relatable and compelling protagonist.
Good Girl, Bad Blood is an engaging read for anyone who enjoys well-crafted mysteries laced with emotional depth and contemporary issues. It will resonate with fans of Jackson’s first book, as well as those who adore a good whodunit filled with social commentary. Ultimately, it reminds us that sometimes, the most complex puzzles lie not just in solving crimes but also in understanding ourselves and the world around us.
If you relish suspense and enjoy character-driven narratives, this book is for you. So, grab a cozy spot, and let Pip’s journey capture your heart and mind, while perhaps prompting you to examine the nature of the relationships in your own life. Happy reading!
Discover more about Good Girl, Bad Blood (A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, #2… on GoodReads >>
